Forums Horror Collectibles
Adam Green Vs. Eli Roth

They both are very talented writers, directors. They Love the genre and have maler styles, meaning lots of blood and guts

Was Just curious who you guys thought was the better overall filmmaker and why. Its a very tough decion for me, but nce Eli Roth hasnt had much activity lately, i'd have to go with Mr. Green. But i really do like Eli Roths work...Hmm maybe i will have to think about it and come back.

Adam Green. I'm not a fan of Eli Roths films.

I like his acting more.

I do respect the guy though.

I don't really understand all the hate for him either.

He is just a huge horror fan thats living his dream.

No need to rip the guy like a lot of people do.

Bitch about Platinum Dunes or something.

But yea I like Adam Green more.

I enjoy all his films and even his shorts.

I'm gonna be the first to utter the name Eli Roth. Just a really talented guy. He does it all acts, writes, directs, and produces movies. I can't wait until "The Man with the Iron Fists" comes out. I think it's gonna be HUGE!!

I agree dude The Man with the Iron Fist will be awesome. RZA knows his kung fu and has so many people backing him.

So i've been thinking about it for a little bit now and im going to have to go with, sorry Mr. Green, but it has to be Mr. Roth. I remember the first time i saw Cabin Fever (yea i know a lot of people didn't like it but i fell in love with it) and hostel in the theaters it had a big impact on me. I'm in love with Hatchet and Hatchet 2, and Frozen was alright (never saw spiral), but when it comes down to it i like Eli Roths approach just a tad better, and i mean just a tad. Very hard decion!!! Mr. Roth needs to hurry and release another movie.

Thanksgiving anyone?

I say we stick 'em both in Thunderdome!

Eli Roth

Mutual respect for both guys, but I'll go with Eli Roth nce he's done a little more. LOVE me some Hatchet though.

I'd have to go with eli roth but it annoys me how hes trying to be an actor now and schmoozing with tarrantino.....not saying green is any slouch either

First off let me say i am a fan of both but ima look at it like this you got Cabin Fever vs Frozen - Hatchet vs Hostel and Hatchet 2 vs Hostel 2.

Cabin fever vs Frozen - I think cabin fever

Hatchet vs Hostel - Hatchet wins Hatchet 2 vs Hostel 2 - Hatchet 2

wins by a lot

so i say Green